About Us
A Little something about us
Something else that might interest you
A Little something about us
I've been making buttertarts for 13 years now, and from what I've been told, I think I've got it figured out.
In 2014, I came in 4th out of 29 at Midland's "Ontario's Best Buttertart Festival".
In 2015, I came in 4th again, but this time it was out of 55, at the same competition.
In 2018, we won "Best Traditional Buttertart", with our Pecan
I've been making buttertarts for 13 years now, and from what I've been told, I think I've got it figured out.
In 2014, I came in 4th out of 29 at Midland's "Ontario's Best Buttertart Festival".
In 2015, I came in 4th again, but this time it was out of 55, at the same competition.
In 2018, we won "Best Traditional Buttertart", with our Pecan tart, at the Markham Buttertart Festival, and in 2019, we won Gold with our "Naked" tart (Plain, nothing in it but butter tart mix). In Feb. 2020, we won the Gold for our pastry.
Something else that might interest you
A Little something about us
We offer amazing homemade, fresh every day buttertarts, made with 100% Gay Lea Butter.
Something else that might interest you
Something else that might interest you
Something else that might interest you
We love what we do, which is making mouth-watering tarts we can be proud of. Every day, we receive compliments about our product, so we must be doing something right.
On a normal day we make anywhere from 1500-1700 tarts. From making and rolling out the pastry, all the way to putting labels on the tarts as they are being readied for delivery (which we also do ourselves)
Stuff we're proud to share
Real testimonials
Nov 22
SARAH E. WINTERBOTTOM
"These are absolutely by far the best butter tarts I have ever tasted (sorry Mom)"
Sept. 15
AMY FELTHAM
"The best butter tarts I've ever had!"
Oct. 17, 2017
LORI RAI AKEY-SMITH
"These tarts are addictive! You can't get better pastry than this!"
Aug. 15
MEAGHAN DAILEY
"Amazing tarts! Some of the best I’ve had! Yum"
Sept. 2019
KATY HB,
Hi there,
I just wanted to give a compliment to Paradise Tarts. I tried my first ever salted caramel tart today and it was absolutely delicious.
I have a tradition of baking tarts with my grandma in the fall each year. I’ve never found a tart that was as good as her secret recipe.. until today when I bit into a Paradise Tart.
Keep up the great work, I look forward to trying the other flavours!
Apr/2020
L. LAIRD, Plainfield, ON
I am a big fan, have been for several years. I buy them at Foxboro Foodland, and I just wanted you to know, in this time of restrictions, that you are appreciated. Paradise Tarts stands head and shoulders above every other local butter tart I’ve tried (and I’ve tried many, including R*&%$’s, the bakery between Port Hope and Cobourg, and other area bakeries.) The crust is perfect, the filling is the right amount of gooiness and firmness, and I’m sure the flavours are all good even though I tend to stick to a few classics.
I made it a personal quest to find the best butter tart, and you are IT. (Can you tell I just ate a Skor butter tart, which inspired me to write this?)
I really hope your business survives this downturn. I want to send you good wishes for success.
Sept. 21, 2020
SEAN KELLY
Program Director & Morning Show Host - Mix 97, Belleville, ON
"Tried your chocolate peanut butter tart at city hall today in Belleville. Delicious!!! Congrats!"
Oct. 18, 2020
MICHELLE LAMADRID
Hi there, we went to Campbell's Orchards yesterday and picked up some plain butter tarts. Oh lawd, they were incredible! We’ve never tasted anything like it. Perfect amount gooey filling, a tiny bit of crunch on the top and I don’t even know where to begin with the incredible crust. It’s the MOST perfect crust! Anyhoo, we went back to Campbell’s orchard today and bought 8 more for our ride back to Toronto. Sadly, we realized it wasn’t enough so I’m hoping you can tell me if you sell your tarts in Toronto or somewhere close to Toronto? Please say you do. PLEASE!?!
Your forever fans,
The Goldberg Family